Pros and Cons of Granite Slabs vs Marble Slabs in the Kitchen
Choosing materials for your culinary space depends on your lifestyle and maintenance preferences. Granite slab for kitchen offers durability and resistance to stains, while marble slab for kitchen provides an elegant look with more upkeep. Consider your daily cooking and cleaning habits to select the countertop that best suits your needs.
Do you find yourself constantly cleaning up spills after cooking with the family? Or do you love hosting guests, but worry about scratches from heavy serving dishes? Maybe you simply want a surface that looks stunning, without demanding too much maintenance.
Granite slab for kitchen and marble slab for kitchen each offer unique benefits, but they also come with their own challenges that can affect your daily routine. This blog can help you understand the pros and cons of both, and will guide you in selecting the countertop that truly fits your lifestyle.
Marble Slab for Kitchen, at a Glance
Marble is a metamorphic rock formed from limestone under extreme heat and pressure within the Earth’s crust. It is composed primarily of calcite, which gives it a smooth, glossy finish and its characteristic veining. The finest marble is quarried from Italy (Carrara and Calacatta), Greece, Turkey, and India.
Large blocks are cut from the mountain face, ensuring minimal damage to the stone’s natural veining. The raw marble blocks are sliced into slabs using gang saws or diamond wire saws. These slabs are then polished to a high-gloss finish using progressively finer abrasives. A sealant is applied to protect the marble countertop surface from stains and moisture, and to preserve its glossy appearance.
Quick Facts
The table below provides an in-depth understanding of the pros and cons of marble slabs for kitchen countertops.
Aspect |
Advantages |
Disadvantages |
Variety and Appearance | Popular choices include Carrara, Calacatta, and Statuario, known for their bright white backgrounds and dramatic grey veining | Colour and pattern variations between slabs can make it difficult to achieve a cohesive look, especially for large kitchens |
Durability and Strength | With proper sealing, marble becomes more resistant to moisture and minor scratches | Heavy impact or objects dropped from a height can damage the surface |
Installation Complexity | Professional installation ensures seamless joints, precise fitting, and structural integrity | Heavy and challenging to handle; incorrect installation of marble countertops can lead to cracks and structural issues |
Maintenance and Care | Daily cleaning with a soft cloth and mild soap is sufficient to maintain its appearance | Improper maintenance or neglecting sealing can result in discolouration, dullness, and even bacterial growth |
Repair and Restoration | Minor scratches can be polished out, and resealing can restore its original look | Chips and cracks are difficult to repair, and may not blend seamlessly with the existing pattern |
Read to know more: Choosing the Right Countertop Material for Your Kitchen
Granite Slab for Kitchen, at a Glance
Granite is a natural stone formed through the slow crystallisation of magma beneath the Earth’s surface. It is composed mainly of quartz, feldspar, and mica, which give it its distinctive speckled appearance. Granite’s journey from the earth to your kitchen countertop is facilitated by quarries in India, Brazil, China, and Italy.
Large blocks are cut from the earth using diamond wire saws, explosives, or specialised machinery. Once cut into slabs, the granite undergoes multiple stages of refinement. The rough surfaces are polished using abrasive pads and diamond polishing wheels.
The slabs are then treated with sealants to make them resistant to stains and moisture. Quality checks ensure that each slab is free from cracks or imperfections, before being shipped to distributors and fabricators worldwide.
Quick Facts
This table provides an in-depth understanding of the pros and cons of granite slabs for kitchen countertops.
Aspect |
Advantages |
Disadvantages |
Variety and Appearance | Popular choices include Black Galaxy, Blue Pearl, and Kashmir White, known for their rich colours and striking patterns. | Due to its natural formation, colour and pattern variations between slabs can make it challenging to achieve a uniformed look |
Durability and Strength | Granite slabs are some of the hardest natural stones – making them highly resistant to scratches, heat, and impact | Although highly durable, excessive force from sharp objects can cause scratches or chips – particularly on polished surfaces |
Installation Complexity | Granite can be custom cut into various shapes and sizes, including custom edges and backsplashes | Skilled professionals are required for precise cutting, fitting, sealing – as granite is heavy & brittle, and incorrect installation can lead to cracking and structural issues |
Maintenance and Care | Sealing is required only once every 1-2 years, making it a low-maintenance option compared to marble | Using acidic or abrasive cleaners can damage the sealant and dull the surface – so special granite cleaners are recommended |
Repair and Restoration | Minor scratches and stains can be polished out by professionals, restoring its original shine. Patina that develops over time adds to its classic appeal. | Repairs are expensive, and challenging to match with the original pattern and finish |
Read to know more: Granite vs Quartz: Which Countertop Material is Best for Your Kitchen?
Varieties and Pricing
Here is a table outlining the approximate costs of various marble or granite slabs, along with their installation charges.
Type |
Budget-Friendly |
Mid-range |
Premium |
Installation Cost |
Maintenance Cost |
Granite |
₹70-₹120 per sq ft (e.g., Black Pearl, Steel Grey) | ₹120-₹215 per sq ft (e.g., Black Galaxy, Alaska White) | ₹260-₹305 per sq ft (e.g., Rosso Portoro, Blue Pearl) | ₹25-₹45 per sq ft, depending on complexity and location | ₹10-₹30 per sq ft, including sealing and polishing |
Marble |
₹150-₹250 per sq ft (e.g., Indian Marble, Udaipur Pink) | ₹250-₹500 per sq ft (e.g., Carrara, Calacatta) | ₹800-₹2500 per sq ft (e.g., Statuario, Calacatta Gold) | ₹35-₹60 per sq ft, due to specialised handling and fitting | ₹20-₹50 per sq ft, including regular sealing and special cleaning products |
Please note that these are approximate figures, and actual costs can vary based on factors such as location, supplier, and specific project requirements. It is advisable to obtain quotes from multiple suppliers and contractors, to get the most accurate pricing for your kitchen project.
Conclusion
By now, you would have a clearer understanding of whether granite slab for kitchen or marble slab for kitchen suits your needs and lifestyle. If durability and low maintenance are your priorities, granite may be the ideal choice. On the other hand, if you value elegance and do not mind a bit of upkeep, marble could be the perfect fit. In the end, the decision boils down to how you use your kitchen and the look you want to achieve.
Read to know more: A Guide to Selecting the Best Countertops for Your Kitchen
FAQs
1. Are marble slabs high-maintenance compared to granite?
Yes, marble slabs are high-maintenance compared to granite, as they are prone to staining and scratching.
2. Which is more durable, granite or marble, for kitchen countertops?
Granite is more durable than marble for kitchen countertops, due to its resistance to scratches, heat, and stains.
3. Do granite countertops require sealing?
Yes, granite countertops require sealing to maintain their stain resistance, but they generally need less frequent sealing compared to marble.
4. Is marble a good choice for a high-use kitchen?
No, marble is not a good choice for a high-use kitchen, due to its susceptibility to stains and scratches.
Read to know more: Are Marble Slabs Suitable for High-Use Kitchens?